Election Predictions Postmortem 2026

Alicia and I spent Election Day on the road across Nashua and ended it at Fody’s Tavern, watching the results come in with some incredible people. In between, we drove to every ward in the city to collect check-in counts, and stopped along the way to talk with people at the polls. Those counts fed the turnout estimates that ran on the site all day.

Who brings a computer to a bar??

Then the polls closed, and the night got interesting fast. A new twist this year: several wards run two counting machines, and each machine prints its own results tape. My upload tool had been built for one tape per ward, so the second tapes broke it. To everyone who witnessed my face last night, I’ll admit I was stressed (a quick apology to anyone who caught me in that moment). Just as a point: if I was stressed having to pivot, you can imagine what the City Clerk’s Office had to deal with to get the official results out. I was able to patch the software on the spot by adding each ward’s two tapes together into one before uploading, and the results started to flow.

The moment the first ward came in

Ward 4 was the first full result we entered: 2,064 ballots, about 6% of the city’s vote. Within seconds the forecast moved, and it moved a lot.

The model compares each ward with how that ward usually votes. Ward 4 is always Nashua’s most Democratic ward, but this time Democrats were running 4 to 7 points ahead of even that. The model applied that shift across the city, and the Nashua governor’s race flipped from a narrow Ayotte lead to Cinde Warmington. That’s how it ended.

That was the first real sign of the night: the polls had been too cautious about Democrats, and one ward had already shown us by how much.

As the wards rolled in: what the model got right

Wards 9 and 6 came next, then the rest of the city, and with every tape the room got more excited. Each new result mostly confirmed what Ward 4 had suggested.

  • One ward was enough to correct most of the polling miss. Before results, the model was off by about 3.6 points in a typical Nashua race. After Ward 4 alone, it was off by less than half a point.
  • Turnout. We expected about 33,000 Nashua voters. The final count was 33,400.
  • The winners. With all nine wards in, the model had Chris Pappas winning the Senate race, Maggie Goodlander keeping her seat in Congress, and Kelly Ayotte winning re-election as governor. All three happened. Its statewide Senate and Congress estimates came within a fraction of a point of the actual results.
  • The State House seats. It gave Democrats about a 76% chance of winning all 27 of Nashua’s seats, and they won all 27. It flagged Ward 9, where Rep. Bill Ohm has a personal following, as the one to watch. Ward 9 was the closest seat in the city, decided by 296 votes.
  • The way the wards vote in relation to each other are pretty close from election to election. This is the heart of why one ward could predict how everything would relatively shape up. When Sherry Dutzy won Ward 4 by the margin she did, you could almost predict how the next set of wards would vote. That’s why, as soon as Ward 4 came in, the model changed in her favor. When Ward 9 followed and corroborated the relative voting pattern, you could tell that it was going to be a long night for Dave Fredette.
  • The County and State Senate Races could confidently be called early once a ward result came in, but with a catch. It was obvious that once this shift was seen in one ward and corroborated by another that Melanie Levesque and Carryl Roy would win… partially because the shift showed them up by a ton, but also because a shift within a city happens to some degree to an entire state. There is less than a percent probability that a neighboring town will somehow retreat into a deeper vote that will contradict what the adjacent town voted. In real terms: you’ll never see Nashua see a blue shift like this, and somehow Hudson doesn’t see a similar shift of some sort in the same election. That’s not a thing. If it happens across 9 wards in Nashua, some degree of that is likely happening all over the state. And it was corroborated by the 3.7 shift NATIONALLY towards the Democrats across the US.

Where it went wrong, and why

Before any results came in, the model had every Nashua race too close. Democrats beat its forecast in all of them, by about 3.5 points of vote share in a typical race and by as much as 6.5.

Race (Nashua)Model before Election DayActual result
GovernorAyotte by 1Warmington by 5.5
U.S. SenatePappas by 19Pappas by 26
CongressGoodlander by 29Goodlander by 31
County AttorneyBennett by 10Bennett by 20
County CommissionerDutzy by 4Dutzy by 17
  • The polls were too Republican, and not just here. The model is built on public polls. The final national polls had Democrats ahead by about 9 points in the race for Congress (RealClearPolling); early estimates have them winning by 13 to 14 (G. Elliott Morris). Even Nate Silver’s forecast, which called the right winners, expected a smaller wave (Silver Bulletin). Turnout wasn’t the problem: about the expected number of people voted, but they leaned more Democratic than the polls expected.
  • Some Republicans’ personal following shrank. The model gave a few Republicans extra credit for running ahead of their party in past years, such as County Commissioner candidate David Fredette. In a wave year, more people vote a straight party line, and in Nashua most of that edge disappeared.
  • One race sat still. The State Senate District 12 estimate didn’t move after the first three wards, because none of them is in that district, even though every other race had just shifted about 4 points.

What we’ll do differently next time

  1. A confidence score on every race. Each race will show how sure the model is that the leader wins. At 90% or higher it will make a call; below that, it says “no call.” Scored that way, this year’s pre-election forecast made 7 calls and got 6 right. The one miss was County Commissioner, at 71%, just over the current line.
  2. Let races without results borrow from races that have them, so no race sits still while everything else moves.
  3. Shrink personal-vote cushions in a wave. When the first wards show a big swing, credit for candidates who usually outrun their party will shrink.
  4. Handle polls better. Include more national polls. Rate pollsters by their track record, flag polls paid for by a party, and watch the newest polls for late movement.
  5. Fix the upload tool for two-machine wards, so each tape can go in on its own and be added up automatically.
  6. The Ben Clemons Gut Check™️. Once the model detected the shift from Ward 4, it adjusted. But it took results to figure out the shift. Colleague and long time Alderman Ben Clemons had predicted something was different this year. So we are implementing The Ben Clemons Gut Check™️ filter in future models to predict Nashua’s results.

    The goal isn’t to predict every margin perfectly; no one did that this year. It’s to get the winners right, be honest about how sure we are, and let the real results correct the picture as fast as possible. Yesterday, that took one ward’s results to see, and two to solidify.

Something new: when Nashua votes, ward by ward

Those check-in counts we collected all day turned out to be valuable on their own. We now have hour-by-hour turnout for every ward from two elections: the 2025 city election and this year’s state election. We can already see that the patterns differ. This year, a bigger share of voters came in early in the morning than the 2025 pattern predicted, and some wards ran behind in the late morning before catching up after work.

That’s practical information for campaigns and volunteers: knowing when each ward is busiest helps decide where and when to send people to hold signs at the polls.

Thank you, Nashua

To everyone who voted, worked the polls, held a sign, or sent us a photo of a results tape: thank you. Alicia and I couldn’t be more excited for everyone across the city and the state, and we can’t wait to do it again.

A New Election Day Voter Experience

With all the millions of dollars invested by parties and campaigns leading up to the election, it’s shocking that the Election Day experience is devoid of experience design for what voters must go through. In short, the Election Day experience for voters just outside the polling place is terrible.

It’s something I’ve always found fascinating. Voters show up to the polls and see people they may/may not know holding signs they may/may not have seen before with names of people they don’t know anything about. I’ve talked about the polling place experience as “visual chaos.”

This is the “visual chaos” paradigm I’m referring to.
Kate Brindley Photography www.katebrindleyphotography.com

The prevailing opinion as to why campaigns and parties make and display totems (the multiple signs stacked on top of each other on a wooden post) is traditionally because:

  1. It’s widely accepted that having support at the polls will influence a voter to vote for whoever is on the sign the supporter is holding. It follows the logic of making signs and putting them all over the place, and it’s a last-minute attempt to sway a voter into voting for that individual or set of individuals.
  2. If you stack two or three signs on top of each other, you will put candidates who are running for lesser known positions (i.e., “down ballot candidates”) with other more high profile candidates to associate them with the same approach to governing. It’s thought that this can “elevate” that candidate’s profile and garner them more votes.

There are many major challenges with this thinking:

  1. You’re not taking into account anything about the voter (what kind of day they’re having, where their headspace is at). You are simply asking them to perform something.
  2. It assumes that many voters respond positively to these signs, when we have seen that most voters go out of their way to avoid the locations where people and signs are.
  3. Many voters see supporters and those involved in political support as “extreme.”
  4. You are assuming that the voter has any clue who any of the people are on your totem. If it’s a presidential year, or a mayoral race, they may know the top people on the ballot, but the farther you go down the ballot, the more unknown people are.
  5. Voting is a private matter between the voter and the vote. Asking for votes the day of the election can be seen as an extreme turnoff or a harassment tactic, especially to those who want to maintain their privacy.

These emotional and rational reasons are important to take into consideration for all of us as we struggle to convince Americans to stay engaged in our political system. We need the polls to be welcoming, less frenzied, and pleasant. We need to project a relaxed environment for all voters as they make some pretty important decisions for our towns, cities, states and federal governments.

In some towns, they were handing out water bottles to those people who were waiting in line for hours to vote. While that seems like a nice thing to do, it can also be seen as an attempt to “buy” a vote. What experience should political campaigns and parties be striving to create a successful outcome? Here are five tips:

Drop ALL the attacks and smears.
If a campaign is still attacking their opponent on the day of the Election and is bringing signs out to do so, the message you send to many voters is that you don’t care about what they’re going through that particular day. You need to be able to shift your attention away from grievance politics and focus on the time voters are taking out of their day to show up at the polls.

Thank voters for their time and try to establish a small personal connection.
While I’ve seen many people in polling places thank others for coming out, many of the folks who hold signs remain silent and let their yard sign totems do the talking. I’ve also noticed that when someone is LEAVING the polls, most responses shift from thanking voters to “So who did you vote for?” leaving a voter in what could be an awkward position for them. Find ways to focus on thanking them. They may even vote for your person next time because of the way you made them feel.

Re-think why your supporters are out there and how they can help you.
I’m going to ask every candidate who’s in charge of a campaign: does having a sign out there with your name on it really add to your voting day totals? Voters come in knowing who they’re going to vote for at the very top of the ballot. I always laugh when I see people with Trump or Biden signs out there at the polls (as if that will dramatically impact the amount of votes they were going to get that day). Having a supporter out there should be a reflection of who you are and who you want to be. What can you do to arm them with the training and tools that will leave a lasting impression on a voter? Supporters should be removing the chaos from the voter AND simplifying things for them.

Leaders need to lead. Support your lesser known candidates and teams.
This is probably the most important thing to note: Up to 40% of voters don’t know who their party’s down ballot candidates are (i.e., the candidates running for lesser known positions who are being supported by their parties). The entire system of politics gravitates towards the more powerful positions, and leaves the lesser positions within town and municipal government with less resources and money. If your campaign team simply focuses on getting the top position filled and none of your team members (for example, a laser focus on Mayor and none on your Board of Aldermen), even if you fill the top position, you won’t be able to assert any change once that person gets elected.

What could a new experience look like?

In Nashua, I’m experimenting with a brand new design experience at the polls, taking all of the removing the totems where we can and finding new types of messaging for our voters. I created a “triplicate” last election that looked like this:

These three signs, each 2′ x 5′, come together to form a sign that voters may be interested in interacting with. Plus it’s always great to make a sign with my beautiful wife on it.

Two important things to mention about this design: first, it had a huge map of the ward which allowed people to say “hey, that’s where I live!” and point to a section of the sign. Then it associated a really important message with the three candidates (who were in lesser known positions, but very important state legislators): “Thank you for voting.” The voters were drawn in by the design of the sign, then they would smile based on the message, which was VERY different from the typical “VOTE FOR OUR CANDIDATE” messaging that you see prevalent everywhere.

That was great for these three people (who subsequently won their elections and got more votes than people farther up the ballot), but what about the rest of the people running? The back of each was designed to give a bit more information about who was part of the larger team:

Signs for the Democratic candidates up and down the ballot in Nashua (2022)

Did everyone on this ballot get elected? No(though most did). We have a Republican governor who has a great deal of cross-appeal in New Hampshire. Sometimes, it’s the lasting impression you have on people that help you carry a message to win another day. It was a great way to give voters a personal touch on the day of the election, making it more welcoming for them and easier for candidates to connect. I’m proud to say that these signs addressed all of the five points above, welcomed voters into our polling places, and thanked them for the time they spent there, even if they didn’t vote the way we wanted them to.

I’m making modifications to signs for the upcoming municipal elections (version 2.0), and I will keep everyone posted!

Rise Up.

I’ve been slowly turning over Roshi operations to others, and as well, retiring from World’s Toughest Mudder as of next year. Other than turning my attention towards innovative stuff at Apple, why am I doing these things?

Stripping away all of my faults, I know what I’m good at. I am very good at bringing large groups of experts together to agree on and solve complex issues. That’s how I’ve survived and thrived at a certain fruit company for so long. And at my core, while cheesy to say, I really love seeing people achieve their dreams.

So… I’ve decided that I want to fulfill my childhood dream, and run for elected office.

Whoa, slow down. It’s not going to happen right away.  I have a vision of how I’d like to do it, and will reveal more as time goes on.

In the meantime, I’m reaching out to my friends and communities to support me if they think I’ll be any good.  My stances are on that page, and my analysis for solutions of the problems outlined in the stances will be highlighted on this blog.

I’m pretty excited.

I won’t tell you which one I am. But standing to my immediate left is Endicott Peabody, former Democratic Governor of Massachusetts and a mentor to me as a child.  There is also a Republican in this photo.